Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Sesame Street Stuffed Animals by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Sesame Street Stuffed Animals
No. 1 
Sesame Street Friends Cookie Monster, Big Bird, and Oscar 8-inch 3-piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just...
- Just Play is a leading manufacturer of toys for kids of all ages; We hope your child enjoys our products ranging from cute plushie stuffed animals, dolls, styling heads, dress up and pretend play,...
- Cookie Monster, Big Bird, Oscar - Bundle Pack
- PLUSH BASIC
- Includes: Cookie Monster, Big Bird, and Oscar plush toys
Save $2.51No. 2 
GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11”
- SESAME STREET ABBY CADABBY PLUSH: This adorable plush features Abby with sheer iridescent wings and her signature sky-blue dress, holding a yellow flower with a smile. She also features soft pink...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality standards....
- GUND Easter Basket Essentials: Fill your Easter basket with GUND plushies - from the cutest Easter bunny to teddy bears to Peter Rabbit and Hello Kitty plush, our super soft, squishy toys make great...
- QUALITY CUDDLES: Our award-winning bears and toys appeal to animal lovers everywhere, known for their unmatched quality and huggable designs. From toddler toys to adults of all ages, GUND plush is...
- PREMIER PLUSH: As one of America’s oldest teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. To this day, we proudly carry this legacy and stand by...
Save $2.00No. 3 
Just Play Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month
- This product has polybag packaging that may reveal what's inside and cannot be hidden.
- Includes: Bert and Ernie plush toys.
- Take-AlongFriends: The Sesame Street Friends Plush Bundle features 2 characters as small, 8-inch plush toys that are ideal for kids to take anywhere.
- Cuddly Plush Pals: The Sesame Street Friends Plush stuffed toys are made entirely of soft, huggable fabrics and 100% recycled fill.
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Preschoolers will love making up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable pair.
No. 4 
GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13”
- ELMO TAKE ALONG BUDDY: Elmo is here as a cuddly plush perfectly sized for adventure This adorable 13” plush features Elmo with embroidered facial details, super-soft bright red plush, and floppy...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality standards....
- GUND Easter Basket Essentials: Fill your Easter basket with GUND plushies - from the cutest Easter bunny to teddy bears to Peter Rabbit and Hello Kitty plush, our super soft, squishy toys make great...
- QUALITY CUDDLES: Our award-winning bears and toys appeal to animal lovers everywhere, known for their unmatched quality and huggable designs. From toddler toys to adults of all ages, GUND plush is...
- PREMIER PLUSH: As one of America’s oldest teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. To this day, we proudly carry this legacy and stand by...
No. 5 
Sesame Street Friends Elmo and Abby Cadabby 8-inch 2-piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play
- This product has polybag packaging that may reveal what's inside and cannot be hidden.
- Includes: Elmo and Abby Cadabby plush toys.
- Take-Along Friends: The Sesame Street Friends Plush Bundle features 2 characters as small, 8-inch plush toys that are ideal for kids to take anywhere.
- Cuddly Plush Pals: The Sesame Street Friends Plush stuffed toys are made entirely of soft, huggable fabrics and 100% recycled fill.
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Preschoolers will love making up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable pair.
No. 6 
GUND Sesame Street Furry Friends Forever Tango Plush, Premium Stuffed Animal for Ages 1 and Up, Brown/Cream, 7”
- SESAME STREET TANGO PLUSH: Tango, Elmo’s adorable music-loving friend, is here as a cuddly plush This 7” smiling Tango features large, expressive embroidered eyes, cream-and-brown fluffy fur, and...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This cute Furry Friends Forever Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND...
- GIFTS FOR KIDS AND COLLECTORS: Our plush toys, dolls, teddy bears and stuffed animals make impressive birthday gifts, stocking stuffers, and more Our vast collection of Sesame Street toys and...
- QUALITY CUDDLES: Our award-winning bears and toys appeal to animal lovers everywhere, known for their unmatched quality and huggable designs. From infants and toddlers to adults of all ages, GUND toys...
- PREMIER PLUSH: As one of America’s oldest teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. To this day, we proudly carry this legacy and stand by...
Save $4.43No. 7 
GUND Sesame Street Official Mecha Builder Elmo Plush, Stuffed Animal for Ages 1 and Up, 13"
- MECHA BUILDER ELMO PLUSH: This 13” plush features Elmo in his soft, shiny bright red armor as seen in the Sesame Street Mecha Builders animated series. Mecha Elmo has a squeezable body and sturdy...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This Sesame Street Mecha Builder plush toy is made from soft, huggable materials and features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning. See hangtag for details. Appropriate for...
- GIFTS FOR KIDS AND COLLECTORS: Our plush toys, dolls, teddy bears and stuffed animals make impressive birthday gifts, stocking stuffers, and more Our vast collection of Sesame Street toys and...
- QUALITY CUDDLES: Our award-winning bears and toys appeal to animal lovers everywhere, known for their unmatched quality and huggable designs. From toddler toys to adults of all ages, GUND plush is...
- PREMIER PLUSH: As one of America’s oldest teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. To this day, we proudly carry this legacy and stand by...
No. 8 
Just Play Sesame Street Big Hugs 18-inch Large Plush Cookie Monster Stuffed Animal, Blue, Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 3 Up
- Includes: Cookie Monster plush toy.
- Perfect Size to Cuddle: The Sesame Street Big Hugs Cookie Monster plush toy is 18 inches tall and features wide-open arms, ready for a big hug. Incredibly soft, kids won’t be able to resist...
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Cookie Monster loves to eat and share his snacks with friends. Preschoolers will love to make up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable Cookie Monster...
- Sustainable, Huggable Plushie: This large Cookie Monster plushie is made entirely of super-soft, cuddly fabrics and 100% recycled polyester fill. Kids will want to hug him during nap time, bedtime,...
- Collect Them All: Sesame Street Big Hugs Plush Julia, Cookie Monster, and Elmo stuffed animals are each sold separately.
Save $10.64No. 9 
Just Play Sesame Street Walk & Wag Tango 8 Inch Plush, Sustainable Stuffed Animal, Soft Plushie, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month
- Includes: Tango interactive plush toy.
- Playtime with Tango: Surprise a special Sesame Street fan with Tango, the cutest pup on Sesame Street.
- Sounds and Motion: The Sesame Street Walking Tango stuffed animal walks, yips, and makes realistic barking sounds. Press Tango’s head to start the fun.
- Encourages Imaginative Play: Preschoolers can make up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable 8-inch-tall Tango plushie.
- Sustainable Stuffed Animal: This cherished Sesame Street toy is made with irresistibly soft materials and recycled polyester fill for less impact on the environment.
No. 10 
Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo Plush, Cookie Monster Plush, Abby Cadabby Plush & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Elmo Stuffed Animal Toys
- Sesame Street Toys: Kids Preferred presents the Sesame Street Elmo's World 4 Piece Gift Set featuring super soft plush toys of your favorite characters. These cuddly companions are great for...
- Caring Friends: Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby, and Big Bird are ready to join in on the adventure! Whether it's a road trip, a long flight, or just being room decor, these huggable toddler toys...
- Safe for All Ages: Designed with ultra-soft materials and baby-safe construction, this set is great for all ages. Parents can rest assured that their little ones are playing with safe and cuddly toys
- Modern Classic Toys: These Sesame Street characters are instantly recognizable and bring sweet memories from the show and movies to you and your children
- Your Favorite Sesame Street Characters in One Set: The 4 piece set includes 6 inch plushies of Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby, and Big Bird. Your baby will love playing and cuddling with their...
Last update on 2025-04-10
