Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Sesame Street Plush Puppets by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Sesame Street Plush Puppets
No. 1 
GUND Sesame Street Official Cookie Monster Muppet Plush Hand Puppet, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 11”
- SESAME STREET COOKIE MONSTER HAND PUPPET: This 11” hand puppet features the classic Muppet with soft, shaggy bright blue plush, Cookie Monster’s large googly eyes, and his excited, friendly...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush hand puppet toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality...
- GIFT GUND: Our stuffed animals, teddy bears, and sensory toys make timeless birthday and baby shower gifts, home decor, and gifts for every other occasion. Our official Sesame Street plushies are...
- Quality Cuddles: Our plush toys feature timeless designs and durable fabrics that stay soft for years. From cute stuff like baby toys, decor, and playsets to anime merch and more, GUND toys are made...
- Premier Plush: As one of America’s first teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. Today we proudly carry this legacy and stand by our toys,...
No. 2 
Sesame Street Cookie Monster 9-inch Hand Puppet, Preschool Pretend Play, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play
- Includes: Cookie Monster hand puppet.
- Creative Fun with Cookie Monster: Unleash the power of pretend play with the Sesame Street Cookie Monster Hand Puppet.
- Fuel Imaginative Play: The fuzzy Cookie Monster hand puppet lets kids pretend to be their favorite Muppet character. Kids can act out Sesame Street scenes from their own imagination and pretend to...
- Encourage Skill Development: Tailored for small hands, the Cookie Monster hand puppet enhances dexterity and nurtures self-confidence through performances for family or friends.
- Super-Soft, Sustainable Fabrics: Crafted from soft fabrics, this 9-inch-tall Cookie Monster plush puppet is stuffed with 100% recycled fill.
No. 3 
Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set - Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys
- BATH TIME ESSENTIAL: Perfectly playful companion for your child’s bath time. Completely waterproof and dries quickly.
- EDUCATIONAL: Excellent for helping teach your child colors, counting, and more!
- EASTER BASKET FILLERS: Makes for great Easter basket and egg fillers!
- SOFT & DURABLE: Made of soft, thick, waterproof, and durable PVC, to hold up playtime after playtime whether in the bath or out.
- FAVORITE CHARACTERS: 10 Pieces including 2 Elmo, 2 Big Bird, 2 Abby Cadabby, 2 Cookie Monster & 2 Oscar the Grouch!
No. 4 
Sesame Street Friends 8-inch Cookie Monster Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animal, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play
- Includes: Cookie Monster plush toy.
- Take-Along Sesame Street Friend: The Sesame Street Friends Plush assortment features favorite characters as small, 8-inch plush toys that are perfect for kids to take anywhere.
- Cuddly Plush Pal: The Sesame Street Friends Plush Cookie Monster stuffed toy is made entirely of soft, huggable fabrics and 100% recycled fill. Awesome for anytime snuggles!
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Preschoolers will love making up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable Cookie Monster plushie. Fuzzy Cookie Monster has a big, happy smile and is ready to...
- Collect Them All: Collect all the Sesame Street Friends Plush toys and have a Sesame Street neighborhood block party! Look for Elmo, Cookie Monster, Big Bird, Ernie, Bert, Oscar, and Abby Cadabby,...
No. 5 
GUND Sesame Street Official Grover Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Blue, 14.5”
- SESAME STREET GROVER PLUSH: This tall 14.5” plush toy features Grover looking ready for playtime with super-soft, shaggy blue plush, a round, pink nose, and his adorable friendly smile. Perfect for...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality standards....
- GIFTS FOR KIDS AND COLLECTORS: Our plush toys, dolls, teddy bears and stuffed animals make impressive birthday gifts, stocking stuffers, and more Our vast collection of Sesame Street toys and...
- Quality Cuddles: Our plush toys feature timeless designs and durable fabrics that stay soft for years. From cute stuff like baby toys, decor, and playsets to anime merch and more, GUND toys are made...
- Premier Plush: As one of America’s first teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. Today we proudly carry this legacy and stand by our toys,...
No. 6 
GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13”
- SESAME STREET ELMO PLUSH: This adorable 13” plush toy features everybody’s favorite Muppet with super-soft shaggy red plush and his wide, friendly smile. Bring home your favorite Sesame Street...
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality standards....
- GIFT GUND: Our stuffed animals, teddy bears, and sensory toys make timeless birthday and baby shower gifts, home decor, and gifts for every other occasion. Our official Sesame Street collection is...
- Quality Cuddles: Our plush toys feature timeless designs and durable fabrics that stay soft for years. From cute stuff like baby toys, decor, and playsets to anime merch and more, GUND toys are made...
- Premier Plush: As one of America’s first teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. Today we proudly carry this legacy and stand by our toys,...
No. 7 
Sesame Street Friends 8-inch Abby Cadabby Sustainable Plush Stuffed Toy, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month by Just Play
- Includes: Abby Cadabby plush toy.
- Take-Along Sesame Street Friend: The Sesame Street Friends Plush assortment features favorite characters as small, 8-inch plush toys that are perfect for kids to take anywhere.
- Cuddly Plush Pal: The Sesame Street Friends Plush Abby Cadabby stuffed toy is made entirely of soft, huggable fabrics and 100% recycled fill. Awesome for anytime snuggles!
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Preschoolers will love making up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable Abby Cadabby plushie. Pretty Abby has a big, happy smile and is ready to be every...
- Collect Them All: Collect all the Sesame Street Friends Plush toys and have a Sesame Street neighborhood block party! Look for Elmo, Cookie Monster, Big Bird, Ernie, Bert, Oscar, and Abby Cadabby,...
No. 8 
Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set
- Includes: Bert and Ernie plush toys.
- Take-AlongFriends: The Sesame Street Friends Plush Bundle features 2 characters as small, 8-inch plush toys that are ideal for kids to take anywhere.
- Cuddly Plush Pals: The Sesame Street Friends Plush stuffed toys are made entirely of soft, huggable fabrics and 100% recycled fill.
- Inspires Imaginative Play: Preschoolers will love making up stories and Sesame Street adventures with this lovable pair.
- The Sesame Street Friends Plush Bundle is ideal for kids ages 2 years and up, and Sesame Street fans of all ages.
No. 9 
GUND Sesame Street Official Ernie Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Orange, 13.5”
- SESAME STREET ERNIE PLUSH: This cute 13.5” plush features Ernie in his iconic striped shirt and blue pants, with soft orange plush, a friendly smile, and a tuft of black hair. Bert also available....
- SOFT & HUGGABLE: This adorable Sesame Street plush toy features surface-washable construction for easy cleaning and is made from a soft, premium material that meets our famous GUND quality standards....
- PERFECT GIFTS: Our plush dolls, teddy bears and stuffed animals make memorable birthday gifts, stocking stuffers, and more Our official Sesame Street collection is perfect for fans and collectors of...
- Quality Cuddles: Our plush toys feature timeless designs and durable fabrics that stay soft for years. From cute stuff like baby toys, decor, and playsets to anime merch and more, GUND toys are made...
- Premier Plush: As one of America’s first teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. Today we proudly carry this legacy and stand by our toys,...
No. 10 
GUND Sesame Street Official Toothpick Super Grover Plush, Plush Muppet, Sensory Toy, Sesame Street Stuffed Animals, Kids Gifts, Blue, 15”
- Toothpick Super Grover Plush: Super Grover’s here to play This irresistibly soft plush toy features the friendly blue Muppet dressed in his hot pink satin cape, knight’s helmet, and he features an...
- Sesame Street Toothpick Plush: This cuddly collection is inspired by Toothpick, a GUND classic teddy bear These soft toys measure 15” and feature slender, posable bodies with long, playfully floppy...
- GIFT GUND: Our stuffed animals, teddy bears, and sensory toys make timeless birthday and baby shower gifts, home decor, and gifts for every other occasion. Our official Sesame Street collection is...
- Quality Cuddles: Our plush toys feature timeless designs and durable fabrics that stay soft for years. From cute stuff like baby toys, decor, and playsets to anime merch and more, GUND toys are made...
- Premier Plush: As one of America’s first teddy bear makers, GUND has crafted unique and classic stuffed animals and soft toys for 125 years. Today we proudly carry this legacy and stand by our toys,...
Last update on 2026-02-14
