Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Colgate Baby Mattresses by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Colgate Baby Mattresses
No. 1 
Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover by Colgate, White - Foam Crib Mattress with Infant Support & Safety Features - Compatible Sleepi Crib/Bed
- COMFORT & SUPPORT - The foam and extra-firm polyethylene layer in the Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover by Colgate provide support & pressure relief so your baby can rest...
- INNOVATIVE MATERIAL - The mattress features an innovative material called NaturesWeave, a matrix of fibers that enhance the open air construction of the mattress and dissipates heat from your child as...
- MADE IN THE USA - Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate. Plus, it’s Greenguard Gold Certified.
- DESIGN WITH A PURPOSE - Stokke entered the children's furniture & accessories sector in 1972, and since then, all our products have been designed to challenge the ordinary, foster healthy development,...
No. 2 
Foam Supreme II Crib Mattress | Lightweight | Hypoallergenic |
- COMFORTABLE: Supportive foam creates an ideal space for your baby to rest and grow during those critical early years
- DURABLE: Tear-resistant, waterproof cover and strong, vinyl binding at the seams to help your crib mattress last longer
- NON-TOXIC: Hypoallergenic & Phthalate free
- SAFE: GREENGUARD Gold, and CertiPUR-US certified. Designed to meet and exceed federal and state flammability requirements; CPSIA compliant
- MEASUREMENTS: 51.8" x 27.5" x 5"; Designed to fit most standard American cribs and toddler beds; Please make sure to measure your crib before placing your order
No. 3 
Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress - Compatible with Sleepi Mini V2 & V3 - Durable, Foam Crib Mattress - Includes Water-Resistant Cover - Made in The USA
- CRAFTED WITH EXPERTISE - The Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress is manufactured by Colgate, a company with over fifty years of experience as a crib mattress specialist.
- COMPATIBILITY - This mattress is compatible with the Sleepi Mini V2 and V3.
- DURABLE - Our firm, strong, durable foam mattress features seams with strong cloth binding and waterproof backing.
- WATER-RESISTANT COVER - Mattress comes with a water-resistant cover made from damask cloth.
- MADE IN THE USA - The Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate.
No. 4 
Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cover by Colgate - Foam Crib Mattress - Compatible Sleepi Mini
- COMFORT & SUPPORT - The foam and extra-firm polyethylene layer in the Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover by Colgate provide support & pressure relief so your baby can rest...
- INNOVATIVE MATERIAL - The mattress features an innovative material called NaturesWeave, a matrix of fibers that enhance the open air construction of the mattress and dissipates heat from your child as...
- MADE IN THE USA - Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cover is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate. Plus, it’s Greenguard Gold Certified.
- DESIGN WITH A PURPOSE - Stokke entered the children's furniture & accessories sector in 1972, and since then, all our products have been designed to challenge the ordinary, foster healthy development,...
Save $17.23No. 5 
Dream On Me Honeycomb Orthopedic Firm Fiber Standard Baby Crib Mattress, Greenguard Gold and JPMA Certified, 5” Fiber Core Optimum Support, Fits...
- SAFETY ALL THE WAY: This Dream On Me Crib Mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified and meets/exceeds all flammability (16 CFR 1632/1633), phthalate and lead tests. It is also designed, engineered, and...
- FIRM SUPPORT FOR YOUR GROWING CHILD: This Mattress has a 5” fiber core that provides the optimum foundation for your growing child and can be used for both infants and toddlers.
- EASY MAINTENANCE: The mattress has a waterproof, vented cover that keeps liquids and stains out to maintain hygienic & safe sleep conditions, and ensure freshness.
- STYLISH FINISH: The mattress comes in a chic, white honeycomb vinyl cover. In case it gets dirty, wipe clean with mild soap and warm water.
- PRODUCT SPECS.: The mattress dimensions are 52” L x 28” W x 5” H and it weighs 8 Lbs.
Save $6.27No. 6 
Dream On Me Holly 3” Fiber Baby Crib Mattress, Fits All Mini & Portable Cribs Only, Greenguard Gold and JPMA Certified Crib Mattress, Easy to Clean...
- EXTRA SUPPORT & COMFORT: The inner core is constructed with firm Eco-fiber for extra support and Embossed Soft Vinyl Cover, Waterproof binding to keeps the mattress fresh adds to the comfort.General...
- SAFETY ASSURED: Greenguard Gold Certified to ensure the highest level of health, safety and peace of mind. Made In the USA –Dream On Me Crib and Toddler Mattresses are designed, engineered and...
- IDEAL CHOICE FOR YOUR MINI CRIBS: This baby mattress fits most mini cribs and portable cribs; mattress measures 38"L x 24"W x 3"H (not designed for standard cribs or pack 'n plays) | measure your crib...
- EASY MAINTENANCE: The mattress is easy to maintain and easily wipes clean with warm water and a mild soap
- LIGHTWEIGHT & DURABLE: The mattress weighs only 2.5lbs and the square corner design adds to its snug fit feature in mini/portable cribs. Warranty: 10 Limited Warranty
No. 7 
Colgate Crib Mattress and Dust Ruffle Protector - Waterproof Pad Protects Mattress from Tears and Rust Stains
- Guards against tears to both mattress and crib Skirt/Dust Ruffle
- Prevents rust stains from nursery vaporizers and humidifiers
- Adds to longevity of mattress
- Waterproof
- Wipes clean with damp cloth & Mild soap
Save $10.00No. 8 
Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress – GREENGUARD Gold Certified & CertiPUR-US Certified, Fits All Standard Crib & Toddler Beds, Waterproof Sleep...
- GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED & CERTIPUR-US CERTIFIED: Our award-winning crib mattress is GREENGUARD Gold Certified for cleaner indoor air for you and your family; Mattress core meets CertiPUR-US program...
- SAFETY CERTIFIED: Free from fiberglass, free from chemical flame retardants; Expert-tested by accredited, third-party laboratories to meet (or exceed) all of the applicable category safety standards;...
- PREMIUM, WATERPROOF OUTER COVER: Features a premium, ultra-soft (and quiet), easy-to-unzip outer cover that has a waterproof sleep surface; Outer cover is machine-washable for quick & easy care;...
- FITS ALL STANDARD FULL-SIZE CRIBS & TODDLER BEDS: Designed to fit any standard full-size baby crib and toddler bed (52 in x 28 in); For optimal performance, open box immediately upon delivery and...
- PAIR WITH GRACO MATTRESS PROTECTOR: For the perfect pair, complete your Graco crib mattress with the matching Graco Premium Waterproof Crib & Toddler Mattress Protector (available in 1-pack and 2-pack...
No. 9 
Serta Perfect Start Limited Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Mattress, Breathable Fiber Core, GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Waterproof, 7 Year...
- WATERPROOF COVER: Waterproof for easy cleaning | Pattern on mattress cover may vary | Breathable fiber core made from recycled bottles delivers ideal firmness level while helping save over 300 bottles...
- DUAL SIDED: Mattress has 2 sides to deliver the best sleeping environment for your growing baby| Flip mattress for freshness as your baby transitions from crib to toddler bed
- CERTIFIED SAFE: GREENGUARD Gold certified for cleaner indoor air quality and low chemical emissions to help create a healthier sleep space | JPMA certified
- NON-TOXIC: This mattress is free from added toxic fire retardants, lead and phthalates | Tested to meet or exceed all applicable JPMA, CPSIA and ASTM safety testing standards
- FITS STANDARD FULL-SIZE CRIBS & TODDLER BEDS: This mattress is designed to fit any standard full-size crib or toddler bed | Size: 52”L x 27.5”W x 5.5”H | Made in the USA | Mattress is backed by...
No. 10 
Newton Baby Essential Crib Mattress - Safe, Ultra-Breathable & Machine Washable Infant Crib Mattress, Removable Cover, Thick Cushion - White
- BREATHE-THRU SAFETY: The ONLY crib mattress with a Wovenaire breathe-thru core. Our patented technology ensures optimal breathability, reducing the risk of suffocation and overheating. And because...
- COMPLETELY WASHABLE: The crib mattress that’s completely washable from cover to removable core. Easily wash away accidents, dust mites and allergens for a cleaner, healthier, hypoallergenic sleep....
- BETTER, LONGER SLEEP FOR BABY: Babies sleep longer on Newton.* And they sleep better too. Our essential crib mattress provides optimal air circulation (cooler sleep!), firm support and incredible...
- NON-TOXIC & GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED: NO foam, glue, latex or springs. Our mattress is independently tested and certified for low chemical emissions, exceeding the highest industry emissions safety...
- INFANT & TODDLER (2-STAGE): One to grow on! Our 2-stage mattress provides your little one with the comfort and firm support they need, all the way through the toddler years.
Last update on 2025-04-18
