Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Colgate Baby Crib Mattresses by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Colgate Baby Crib Mattresses
No. 1 
Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover by Colgate, White - Foam Crib Mattress with Infant Support & Safety Features - Compatible Sleepi Crib/Bed
- COMFORT & SUPPORT - The foam and extra-firm polyethylene layer in the Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover by Colgate provide support & pressure relief so your baby can rest...
- INNOVATIVE MATERIAL - The mattress features an innovative material called NaturesWeave, a matrix of fibers that enhance the open air construction of the mattress and dissipates heat from your child as...
- MADE IN THE USA - Stokke Sleepi Mattress with Organic Cover is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate. Plus, it’s Greenguard Gold Certified.
- DESIGN WITH A PURPOSE - Stokke entered the children's furniture & accessories sector in 1972, and since then, all our products have been designed to challenge the ordinary, foster healthy development,...
No. 2 
Foam Supreme II Crib Mattress | Lightweight | Hypoallergenic |
- COMFORTABLE: Supportive foam creates an ideal space for your baby to rest and grow during those critical early years
- DURABLE: Tear-resistant, waterproof cover and strong, vinyl binding at the seams to help your crib mattress last longer
- NON-TOXIC: Hypoallergenic & Phthalate free
- SAFE: GREENGUARD Gold, and CertiPUR-US certified. Designed to meet and exceed federal and state flammability requirements; CPSIA compliant
- MEASUREMENTS: 51.8" x 27.5" x 5"; Designed to fit most standard American cribs and toddler beds; Please make sure to measure your crib before placing your order
No. 3 
Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cover by Colgate - Foam Crib Mattress - Compatible Sleepi Mini
- COMFORT & SUPPORT - The foam and extra-firm polyethylene layer in the Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cotton Cover by Colgate provide support & pressure relief so your baby can rest...
- INNOVATIVE MATERIAL - The mattress features an innovative material called NaturesWeave, a matrix of fibers that enhance the open air construction of the mattress and dissipates heat from your child as...
- MADE IN THE USA - Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress with Organic Cover is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate. Plus, it’s Greenguard Gold Certified.
- DESIGN WITH A PURPOSE - Stokke entered the children's furniture & accessories sector in 1972, and since then, all our products have been designed to challenge the ordinary, foster healthy development,...
No. 4 
Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress - Compatible with Sleepi Mini V2 & V3 - Durable, Foam Crib Mattress - Includes Water-Resistant Cover - Made in The USA
- CRAFTED WITH EXPERTISE - The Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress is manufactured by Colgate, a company with over fifty years of experience as a crib mattress specialist.
- COMPATIBILITY - This mattress is compatible with the Sleepi Mini V2 and V3.
- DURABLE - Our firm, strong, durable foam mattress features seams with strong cloth binding and waterproof backing.
- WATER-RESISTANT COVER - Mattress comes with a water-resistant cover made from damask cloth.
- MADE IN THE USA - The Stokke Sleepi Mini Mattress is designed by Stokke and handcrafted in the USA by Colgate.
Save $6.27No. 5 
Dream On Me Holly 3” Fiber Baby Crib Mattress, Fits All Mini & Portable Cribs Only, Greenguard Gold and JPMA Certified Crib Mattress, Easy to Clean...
- EXTRA SUPPORT & COMFORT: The inner core is constructed with firm Eco-fiber for extra support and Embossed Soft Vinyl Cover, Waterproof binding to keeps the mattress fresh adds to the comfort.General...
- SAFETY ASSURED: Greenguard Gold Certified to ensure the highest level of health, safety and peace of mind. Made In the USA –Dream On Me Crib and Toddler Mattresses are designed, engineered and...
- IDEAL CHOICE FOR YOUR MINI CRIBS: This baby mattress fits most mini cribs and portable cribs; mattress measures 38"L x 24"W x 3"H (not designed for standard cribs or pack 'n plays) | measure your crib...
- EASY MAINTENANCE: The mattress is easy to maintain and easily wipes clean with warm water and a mild soap
- LIGHTWEIGHT & DURABLE: The mattress weighs only 2.5lbs and the square corner design adds to its snug fit feature in mini/portable cribs. Warranty: 10 Limited Warranty
Save $17.23No. 6 
Dream On Me Honeycomb Orthopedic Firm Fiber Standard Baby Crib Mattress, Greenguard Gold and JPMA Certified, 5” Fiber Core Optimum Support, Fits...
- SAFETY ALL THE WAY: This Dream On Me Crib Mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified and meets/exceeds all flammability (16 CFR 1632/1633), phthalate and lead tests. It is also designed, engineered, and...
- FIRM SUPPORT FOR YOUR GROWING CHILD: This Mattress has a 5” fiber core that provides the optimum foundation for your growing child and can be used for both infants and toddlers.
- EASY MAINTENANCE: The mattress has a waterproof, vented cover that keeps liquids and stains out to maintain hygienic & safe sleep conditions, and ensure freshness.
- STYLISH FINISH: The mattress comes in a chic, white honeycomb vinyl cover. In case it gets dirty, wipe clean with mild soap and warm water.
- PRODUCT SPECS.: The mattress dimensions are 52” L x 28” W x 5” H and it weighs 8 Lbs.
No. 7 
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed - Ultra-Breathable Proven to Reduce Suffocation Risk, 100% Washable, 2-Stage, Non-Toxic Better Than Organic,...
- BETTER SLEEP FOR YOUR LITTLE ONES: Our breathable crib mattress is designed with safety and comfort in mind. The washable wovenaire core provides a completely breathable sleeping surface for your...
- 100% BREATHABLE: With innovative breathe-thru technology, our baby + toddler mattress allows your baby to breathe right through. The patented, supportive core is encased in a soft, detachable cover....
- 100% WASHABLE: The only crib mattress that’s washable from the cover to the core! With a unique design and construction, our washable crib mattress is made from quality materials that fit most...
- INFANT & TODDLER (2-STAGE): Crib mattresses can be a little convoluted, with all sorts of bells and whistles. But one thing is quite simple: your baby’s safety. Our crib mattress is designed with...
- MADE BY PARENTS FOR PARENTS: As parents ourselves, we understand. We know that your baby’s safety comes first, and we also know how much you want to give them the right start in life. As experts in...
No. 8 
Serta Perfect Start Limited Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Mattress, Breathable Fiber Core, GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Waterproof, 7 Year...
- WATERPROOF COVER: Waterproof for easy cleaning | Pattern on mattress cover may vary | Breathable fiber core made from recycled bottles delivers ideal firmness level while helping save over 300 bottles...
- DUAL SIDED: Mattress has 2 sides to deliver the best sleeping environment for your growing baby| Flip mattress for freshness as your baby transitions from crib to toddler bed
- CERTIFIED SAFE: GREENGUARD Gold certified for cleaner indoor air quality and low chemical emissions to help create a healthier sleep space | JPMA certified
- NON-TOXIC: This mattress is free from added toxic fire retardants, lead and phthalates | Tested to meet or exceed all applicable JPMA, CPSIA and ASTM safety testing standards
- FITS STANDARD FULL-SIZE CRIBS & TODDLER BEDS: This mattress is designed to fit any standard full-size crib or toddler bed | Size: 52”L x 27.5”W x 5.5”H | Made in the USA | Mattress is backed by...
No. 9 
Newton Baby Essential Crib Mattress - Safe, Ultra-Breathable & Machine Washable Infant Crib Mattress, Removable Cover, Thick Cushion - White
- BREATHE-THRU SAFETY: The ONLY crib mattress with a Wovenaire breathe-thru core. Our patented technology ensures optimal breathability, reducing the risk of suffocation and overheating. And because...
- COMPLETELY WASHABLE: The crib mattress that’s completely washable from cover to removable core. Easily wash away accidents, dust mites and allergens for a cleaner, healthier, hypoallergenic sleep....
- BETTER, LONGER SLEEP FOR BABY: Babies sleep longer on Newton.* And they sleep better too. Our essential crib mattress provides optimal air circulation (cooler sleep!), firm support and incredible...
- NON-TOXIC & GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED: NO foam, glue, latex or springs. Our mattress is independently tested and certified for low chemical emissions, exceeding the highest industry emissions safety...
- INFANT & TODDLER (2-STAGE): One to grow on! Our 2-stage mattress provides your little one with the comfort and firm support they need, all the way through the toddler years.
No. 10 
Criblike 38’’x24’’ Mini Crib Mattress, Dual-Sided Waterproof Breathable Hypoallergenic, Premium Memory Foam & High Density Foam, Portable...
- [Universal Size] The 38’’x24’’x3’’ baby mattress perfectly fits most mini cribs and portable cribs. (Note: not designed for standard cribs or pack and play). Please measure your crib first...
- [Extra Comfort & Support] We adopt premium memory foam and high density foam to make the mattress giving baby more comfort and support. It could help air flow and reduce body heat. The superior...
- [Dual-Sided Design] The mini crib mattress has dual firmness to provide support and comfort for baby at different growth stages. The high-density support foam side is suitable for babies (0-9 months)...
- [Safety First] The mini crib mattress meets all safety standards by CPSC/ASTM. The overall use of environmentally friendly materials make sure that it has no odors and perfectly safe and healthy for...
- [Delicate and Waterproof Cover] The mattress cover is soft, waterproof, detachable, and machine washable. It is gentle to the touch, hypoallergenic, making it ideal for baby's sensitive skin. The...
Last update on 2025-04-22
