Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated American Girl Dolls by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated American Girl Dolls
No. 1 
American Girl, Summer McKinny Girl of The Year 2025 18-inch Doll and Journal, with Strawberry-Blonde Hair and Blue Eyes, Ages 6+
- An 18" Summer doll with light blue eyes that open and close, and strawberry-blonde hair with light pink ends styled in two face-framing microbraids. She has a soft cotton body, and her movable head...
- A rainbow-patterned knit dress with puffed short sleeves, a smocked waist with a center bow, and a two-tiered skirt
- A pair of pink-and-purple ombre eyeglasses, a pink beaded bracelet, a purple beaded bracelet, a pair of sandals with pink-and-yellow straps and turquoise platform soles, and a pair of underwear
- An illustrated paperback book, My Journal by Summer McKinny, that tells how Summer became the chef of dog treats, stopped the fur wars, and started a business
No. 2 
American Girl WellieWishers 14.5-inch Camille Doll with Blue Leotard, Mermaid Skirt, Headband, and Boots, For Ages 4+
- A 14.5-inch Camille doll that is sized just right for younger girls. She has blue eyes, a freckle on one cheek, and silky blond hair that can be brushed and styled.
- A shiny blue leotard with a mermaid scale foil print on the front
- A sea-blue foil dot mermaid skirt with a coral mesh underskirt and a glitter elastic waistband
- A headband with two shells that feels just like something a mermaid would wear
- A pair of light-pink underwear, plus a pair of blue wellie boots with red fins and smiley fish faces
No. 3 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #107 with Brown Eyes, Brown Hair, Light-to-Medium Skin, Camo T-shirt Dress, For Ages 6+
- The 18" Truly Me Doll Has Lifelike Eyes That Open And Close Smoothly; Realistic Hair That Can Be Styled; A Soft Cotton Body; And A Movable Head And Limbs Made Of Smooth Vinyl
- The Show Your Strong Side Outfit: A Camo-Print T-Shirt Dress With Printed Peace; Tiger; And Star Patches; A Pair Of Underwear; And A Pair Of White Boots With A Star On The Toe
- The All About Us Journal
No. 4 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #124 with Brown Eyes, Black-Brown Hair, Lt-to-Med Skin, T-shirt Dress, For Ages 6+, Floral
- The 18" Truly Me Doll Has Lifelike Eyes That Open And Close Smoothly; Realistic Hair That Can Be Styled; A Soft Cotton Body; And A Movable Head And Limbs Made Of Smooth Vinyl
- The Show Your Sweet Side Outfit: A Floral-Print T-Shirt Dress With Leopard-Print Cuffs; A Pair Of Underwear; And A Pair Of Pink Crisscross Espadrilles
- The All About Us Journal
No. 5 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #100 with Blue Eyes, Blonde Hair, Lt-to-Med Skin, Printed T-shirt Dress, For Ages 6+
- The 18" Truly Me Doll Has Lifelike Eyes That Open And Close Smoothly; Realistic Hair That Can Be Styled; A Soft Cotton Body; And A Movable Head And Limbs Made Of Smooth Vinyl
- The Show Your Wild Side Outfit: A Black T-Shirt Dress With Fun Heart; Star; And Unicorn Graphics; A Pair Of Underwear; And A Pair Of Aqua Glitter High-Top Sneakers With Pink Laces
- The All About Us Journal
No. 6 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #110 with Blue Eyes, Blonde Hair w/Highlights, Light Skin, T-shirt Dress, For Ages 6+
- The 18" Truly Me Doll Has Lifelike Eyes That Open And Close Smoothly; Realistic Hair That Can Be Styled; A Soft Cotton Body; And A Movable Head And Limbs Made Of Smooth Vinyl
- The Show Your Sporty Side Outfit: A Light-Purple T-Shirt Dress With Rainbow-Striped Trim And An "Ag Active" Printed Graphic; A Pair Of Underwear; And A Pair Of Sneakers With Stripe Details
- The All About Us Journal
No. 7 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #125 with Hazel Eyes, Curly Blonde Hair, Light Skin w/Warm Olive Undertones, for Ages 6+
- A Truly Me doll is a friend who knows just how to celebrate who your girl is right now. A little artsy? 100% sporty? Someone who is simultaneously strong and wild and sweet? Mix and match to create an...
- The 18" Truly Me doll has lifelike eyes that open and close smoothly, realistic hair that can be styled, a soft cotton body, and a movable head and limbs made of smooth vinyl.
- The Pretty Plaid Outfit: A purple and pink plaid dress with a white Peter Pan collar and an AG monogram on the left chest, a pair of underwear, a pair of white knee socks with a pink stripe detail,...
- The All About Us journal
No. 8 
American Girl WellieWishers 14.5-inch Ashlyn Doll with Pink Leotard, Glitter Skirt, Headband, and Boots, For Ages 4+
- A 14.5-inch Ashlyn doll that is sized just right for younger girls. She has brown eyes, freckled cheeks, and long silky brown hair that can be brushed and styled.
- A petal-pink leotard with printed gold metallic lacing up the front
- A detachable pink glitter skirt with a high-low hem and a gold glitter elastic waistband and bow
- A pink headband with a princess crown
- A pair of light-pink underwear, plus a pair of pink wellie boots that look like glittery golden Mary Janes
No. 9 
American Girl Truly Me 18-inch Doll #126 with Blue Eyes, Wavy Brown Hair, Light Skin w/Warm Olive Undertones, for Ages 6+
- A Truly Me doll is a friend who knows just how to celebrate who your girl is right now. A little artsy? 100% sporty? Someone who is simultaneously strong and wild and sweet? Mix and match to create an...
- The 18" Truly Me doll has lifelike eyes that open and close smoothly, realistic hair that can be styled, a soft cotton body, and a movable head and limbs made of smooth vinyl.
- The Show Your Artsy Side Outfit: A colorful tie-dye-print T-shirt dress, underwear, and a pair of pink gladiator-style sandals
- The All About Us journal
No. 10 
American Girl WellieWishers 14.5-inch Willa Doll with Coral Leotard, Mesh Skirt, Headband, and Boots, For Ages 4+
- A 14.5-inch Willa doll that is sized just right for younger girls. She has hazel eyes and silky strawberry-blond hair in long pigtails that can be brushed and styled.
- A coral velour leotard with satin binding and multi-ruffle sleeves
- A yellow mesh skirt with a multicolored scalloped-hem top skirt and a sparkly waistband
- A headband with green leaves attached
- A pair of light-pink underwear, plus a pair of red wellie boots with sweet ladybug faces
Last update on 2025-05-23
