Baby Stuff Lab compares top-rated Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles by analyzing reviews and customer feedback. You can easily choose the right one from our Editor Pick List.
Top Rated Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles
No. 1 
Murder Most Puzzling: The Missing Will 500-Piece Puzzle
- DISTINCTIVE TWIST ON THE JIGSAW: In this mystery puzzle, the full puzzle image is a secret until you complete the jigsaw, because it contains the crucial clues you need to unravel the mystery. Double...
- PERFECT BLEND FOR MYSTERY AND PUZZLE FANS: For anyone who loves jigsaws and classic mystery stories, this is the ultimate gift. The narrative and illustrations pay homage to beloved creators like...
- COOL OBJECT: With an elegant box shaped like a book, this makes a special gift and an enviable coffee-table centerpiece.
- NOSTALGIC APPEAL: This mystery puzzle revamps a popular jigsaw format from the 1990s, inviting puzzlers to rediscover a nostalgic pastime.
- GORGEOUS ILLUSTRATION: The finished puzzle image is a sumptuous illustration full of rich color, hidden details, and lightly gothic humor.
Save $3.70No. 2 
Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle, Death on The Istanbul Express, 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle, Orange
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
Save $1.77No. 3 
BePuzzled | Unravel the Mystery, Grounds for Murder - Classic Mystery 1000 pc. Jigsaw Puzzle for Thrill-Seekers and Puzzle Enthusiasts!
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
Save $1.60No. 4 
Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Recipe For Murder Jigsaw Puzzle by University Games |Comes with Murder Mystery and Jigsaw Puzzle | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw | For...
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
No. 5 
Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Foul Play & Cabernet, Red
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
No. 6 
The Mystic Maze • 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle from The Magic Puzzle Company • Series One
- The Mystic Maze is a brand new 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle that does a magic trick when you finish it
- Beautiful, original artwork full of tiny details, including over 50 easter eggs to discover as you solve the puzzle
- Mind-blowing magical twist ending: we’re using ideas from visual illusions and magic to make this the most interesting puzzle you’ve ever solved
- Absolutely NO puzzle dust in the box!
- Includes TWO art posters, so multiple people can solve the puzzle together.
Save $3.22No. 7 
Murder Mystery Party, Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle, Murder by The Pyramids, 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
No. 8 
White Mountain Puzzles Hollywood Murder Mystery 1000 Piece Jigsaw Fun Collage Puzzle
- Detective: A murder has been committed in Hollywood. Enjoy time with family as you solve the mystery and find the killer.
- Murder Mystery: The puzzle itself will look different than what you’re seeing on the box. You will have hints and clues with interesting characters all along the way to the solution.
- Artist: This magnificent puzzle was brought to life by Artist Lena Pigareva. She is best known for a passion for creating memorable characters that have personality and an interesting story to tell.
- USA: We take pride in our puzzles so all of them are manufactured in America. They also come with the Happiness Guarantee. We will replace your puzzle for free if you are not happy.
- Quality: White Mountain is known for our precision cutting technique so each piece fits just right. Our puzzles measure 24” x 30” when finished. Visit our store page to see a wide variety of...
No. 9 
The Awakened Artifacts • 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle from The Magic Puzzle Company • Series Four
- The Awakened Artifacts is a brand new 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle that does a magic trick when you finish it.
- Beautiful, original artwork full of tiny details, including over 50 easter eggs to discover as you solve the puzzle
- Mind-blowing magical ending: we’re using ideas from visual illusions and magic to make this the most interesting puzzle you’ve ever solved
- NO puzzle dust! NO single-use plastic! NO stock images or AI-generated art!
- Includes two art posters so multiple people can solve the puzzle together.
Save $4.72No. 10 
Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Alfred Hitchcock, Black
- Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles are more than just a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle - they're a murder mystery waiting to be solved
- READ about the shocking murder mystery in the included short story booklet
- ASSEMBLE the mystery puzzle and uncover hidden clues
- SOLVE the mystery with the secret clues hidden within the jigsaw puzzle
- Use the final pages of the storybook in a mirror to reveal the murderer!
Last update on 2025-06-03
